Please verify that you are not a bot to cast your vote.
Help SupportOur Growing Community
DOTAFire is a community that lives to help every Dota 2 player take their game to the next level by having open access to all our tools and resources. Please consider supporting us by whitelisting us in your ad blocker!
Want to support DOTAFire with an ad-free experience? You can support us ad-free for less than $1 a month!
I honestly debated on whether or not i should have even voted, seems i shouldn't have since everyone seems upset about it, guess i wont next time.
I think 2 weeks for these contests is way to long, i am pretty sure everyone had submitted their ideas in 1 week and it felt like an eternity waiting for the contest to end.
I would recommend shortening it but that's just my opinion, i don't know if anyone else felt like it lasted to long as well.
Really, if you create a hero, you have to vote. Or else your hero would be at an advantage, because it would have 1 more round of votes overall. So if you keep wanting to participate in the contests, your voting is accepted.
I don't want any arguments around. So stop whining, everyone votes as they feel they should. There were a couple of people that actually enterned the contest 1 week after it was posted, this is why I actually made it two weeks long.
Off-topic :
Quoted:
Wulfstan does have a life, you gotta remember that.
EDIT: Wait, does he?
Quoted:
Based on the start bar on that picture of the excel spreadsheet it looks like he does social networking and steam all day...
B:7 (The global tidebringer needs a nerf)
O:8
U:8
L:8
Yzreel
B:7
O:10
U:9
L:9
Oldkainen
B:9
O:8
U:9
L:7
Wulfstan
B:8
O:8
U:8
L:7
Also, will appreciate feedbacks for Ira. :)
Also, Originality is hard for me to decide, because its almost like the lore. I suggest to change to Creativity...?
All these kinds of stuff is exactly why I said to just PM the scores....
So anyway, since everybody already posted here and not by PM, I guess I will also post
Please note that as usual, I am being as objective as possible and I hope there will be no hard feeling
All these kinds of stuff is exactly why I said to just PM the scores....
So anyway, since everybody already posted here and not by PM, I guess I will also post
Please note that as usual, I am being as objective as possible and I hope there will be no hard feeling
I understand, then again, I want people to debate. You see, the point of this contest is to just to be creative in general, not to win. I was thinking about actually adding some sort of a prize (maybe dota related one, or just a random steam game) - but this is the kind of behaviour that stopped me doing it, and this was just a small test.
And now, for my votes
Bunkansee
B:8
O:7
U:8
L:6
Notes : I really liked the idea in general. It seems like a good one, but a tiny bit lackluster, maybe because it has so much stun (but hey, who doesn't like stuns).
F.E.A.R.0
B:5
O:8
U:7
L:7
Notes : This hero felt like he's everywhere. A tiny bit of unit pausing, a huge threshold on his ultimate, and an unrivaled escape mechanism. I don't really think he is balanced, I don't feel anything could really kill him (maybe silencing him)
ThreadOfFate
B:7
O:8
U:9
L:8
Notes : I feel like this guy is probably the easiest one to use out of all the posted ones, if paired up with a good initiation. Reason for 7 instead of 8 at balance is that the ultimate seems quite a bit strong.
P.S : 2 of your skill icons are from the game "Path of Exile", the second one and the last one.
SilencersCurse
B:3
O:8
U:2
L:4
Notes : This actually feels and looks like the most unbalanced thing I've ever seen. So basically, if all 10 heroes are in the ultimate, there's a 10 second stun to everyone to stop the teamfight?You can actually even kill teammates with this, which is even worse. Neither of the skills actually synergyse with each other, it's just let's add more to this guy so he deals more damage. Passive is useless on one side (abandons), overpowered on the other side (deaths).
kkoopman3
B:6
O:9
U:7
L:7
Notes : The only reason why the originality is not 10/10 is because Nebulate is basically a weaker version of Blur in my eyes. Lore was kind of meh, too, a tiny bit too short for my taste. What is worse that actually none of the lores ANY of you come up with have absolutely nothing to do with the DOTA universe. It's like you are trying to expand it, not live inside it.
porygon361
B:8
O:7
U:6
L:8
Notes : Hero itself feels quite unoriginal, with some skills feeling like mashups of current ones. The lore is quite decent, but I don't feel he can actually be used in tantem with any hero in the game. Also, in the first skill description, who/what is Lodestar?
Terathiel
B:6
O:7
U:8
L:10
Notes : First hero lore I see that has any relation to the DOTA 2 universe. 10/10.
Ninecent
B:7
O:8
U:8
L:7
Notes : The ultimate seems quite interesting, it seems like a hex, but without the enemy actually turning into a critter.
Powergoat
B:4
O:7
U:8
L:6
Notes : This guy seems like he is all over again. He can be pretty much every role in the game. While flexibility is good, not sure it does a lot for the balance.
oldKainen
B:9
O:8
U:9
L:5
Notes : This is probably the most balanced idea in the contest. It seems good all around, except the lore part. That's not really the idea's strength.
Unscathed
B:7
O:6
U:8
L:7
Notes : The hero itself is good, however, some skills resemble some skills that are already in game (especially the first one).
Yzreel
B:6
O:10
U:8
L:8
Notes : 10/10 for originality, it's really new and refreshing, however, I do not feel that he is that balanced, his third skill seems a tad strong. Lore was really good and enjoyable to read, even if (again), has no relation to the DOTA 2 universe.
I will wait for ThreadOfFate to submit his votes, then I shall add them all up and see who got the highest score.
I like the notes. Next time I would ask that everybody include notes in their scoring, such as the ones included in Wulfstan's vote. It helps me improve on the idea and see what people like in a hero.
DOTAFire is the place to find the perfect build guide to take your game to the next level. Learn how to play a new hero, or fine tune your favorite DotA hero’s build and strategy.
kkoopman3
Remarkable (28)
Posts: 815
Steam: Ce.W1sd0m
TheSofa
<Moderator>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (54)
Posts: 3318
kkoopman3
Remarkable (28)
Posts: 815
Steam: Ce.W1sd0m
TheSofa
<Moderator>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (54)
Posts: 3318
Powergoat
Notable (4)
Posts: 46
View My Blog
Wulfstan
<Retired Mod>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (77)
Posts: 2801
Steam: Wulfstant
View My Blog
Late credits to Janitsu for the sig
Unscathed
<Editor>
Awards Showcase
Remarkable (47)
Posts: 3432
View My Blog
Yzreel Hero Arsenal
Yzreel
Awards Showcase
Remarkable (30)
Posts: 729
Steam: Yzreel
View My Blog
Wulfstan
<Retired Mod>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (77)
Posts: 2801
Steam: Wulfstant
View My Blog
kkoopman3
Remarkable (28)
Posts: 815
Steam: Ce.W1sd0m