Forge of creation #1 voting !

Forum » Hero & Item Ideas » Forge of creation #1 voting ! 58 posts - page 4 of 6

Instant kill below 50% health? That's a kill threshold, similar to what Culling Blade does. It also deals more damage and has 800 range. It's better than Culling Blade in almost every way, unless I'm reading the 50% or below thing wrong.

There are two kinds of people in the world; those who can count, and those who can't.

Meme central please give me ad revenue

Awards Showcase

Show more awards

Remarkable (49)
Posts: 1415
Steam: Save me from this meme hell
View My Blog

wrote:

It's not a . Even had 50% threshold mechanic but it was removed.

Yes, it was REMOVED, wonder why? and that was in Melee range.

Also, did anyone forget to mention his one button escape? It is near impossible to gank him, with an ability that gives over MAX movespeed, COMPLETE invunerability, and UNDETECTABLE invisibility, even in CHRNOPSHERE! And it causes a slow, and lasts FOREVER.

Notable (4)
Posts: 46
View My Blog

wrote:

To be fair, I didn't look at any of the hero ideas in the entries thread until I posted mine so I don't subconsciously copy any idea. It was just the overlap in themes that made us choose abilities with the same effect. Also, I've already made 2 hero ideas with the same theme, so I ran out of material to use for this one.

I've also seen some other notes you've made, and the one for Bunkansee's makes it seem like you have a limited understanding of dota. Just because a hero has to combo with other heroes to be strong doesn't mean that it is underwhelming. Take for example. A hero that has all skills that rely on "combo-ing" with its teammates. Is that bad? No! The patented - duo is very powerful. What I'm saying here is that reliance on teammates does not make a hero weak. Otherwise, all supports would be weak by that definition.

For Bunkansee

What makes this even more unfair is that he gave everyone a score less than or equal to 5, while he gives himself nigh perfect scores (that's not even allowed lawl).

But what is done is done. It's his call, not mine. (Just ignore the score he gave himself, it's obvious that he's trolling.)

Yes rating myself was just a joke, didn't think you guys would take it seriously, i even made a silly note for myself to make it clearer that it was just that. Also i understand fully well some heroes can combo well with others but that was not the point of this contest nor what i was referring to when i made my note, as a stand alone hero in my opinion alone, it seemed on the weak side, that is all. As for the low scores i meant no offence i'm just a harsh critic, my idea was not perfect either. Also i never meant to insinuate you copied me in any way, i was just merely pointing out the similarities.

Posts: 57

I feel like I graded rather fairly. Ask me any questions about certain scores and I will try to answer them.

Porygon361:
B: 8
O: 9
U: 9
L: 8

F.E.A.R.0:
B: 6
O: 7
U: 6
L: 7

Bunkansee:
B: 6
O: 5
U: 8
L: 6

Yzreel:
B: 8
O: 9
U: 9
L: 9

ThreadOfFate:
B: 7
O: 8
U: 7
L: 9

kkoopman3:
B: 9
O: 7
U: 7
L: 7

Wulfstan:
B: 8
O: 9
U: 7
L: 8

SilencersCurse:
B: 6
O: 9
U: 5
L: 5

Terathiel:
B: 5
O: 9
U: 8
L: 7

Ninecent:
B: 9999
O: 9999
U: 9999
L: 9999

oldKainen:
B: 8
O: 8
U: 9
L: 6

Powergoat:
B: 6
O: 8
U: 8
L: 6

Unscathed:
B: 8
O: 8
U: 7
L: 7

Notable (3)
Posts: 84

wrote:

I get you might be a harsh critic, but on your comments it just seemed that you were also not a very through one. Ex. The only comment you wrote on mine was "global tidebringer". If you really compared the abilities you would see that I took care to make it very significantly not so. The damage is not cleave damage, is not based upon the possible damage but the damage taken, and the "cleave" is magic damage so it is reduced another 25%. In comparison, tidebringer is a 100% cleave that also deals bonus damage, so it has the potential to 1 shot teams.

Notable (4)
Posts: 46
View My Blog

wrote:

Your right it is very different, its just what i thought of when reading the skill its more like fatal bonds with a cooldown on damage intervals.

Also finished the rest of the hero ideas.

Posts: 57

Silencer mate. Ik ur a harsh critic, but I still take offense to my lore's low rating. What was wrong with it?

Also, add some positive notes instead of focussing on negatives.

Notable (14)
Posts: 627
Steam: TTT.Pixelmancer
View My Blog

wrote:

Hm, well I don't think the competition was made to make heroes which didn't combo well. I made a support hero, which of course needs to combo with someone. I don't know what you mean in "so i understand fully well some heroes can combo well with others but that was not the point of this contest". I believe it is a type of hero which can be submitted, it's not a "make the best carries which are super good on their own" contest. I don't mind getting low ratings, but I don't agree with the fact this competition was made for heroes which don't need to combo.

Awards Showcase

Show more awards

Remarkable (32)
Posts: 1373
Steam: Bunkansee

I agree with Bunkan on this one. a support hero is just that, a hero. If the hero possesses support skills I think the idea needs to be assessed based on how well they can support, not how quickly they'd die in a solo situation.

Remarkable (28)
Posts: 815
Steam: Ce.W1sd0m

I honestly debated on whether or not i should have even voted, seems i shouldn't have since everyone seems upset about it, guess i wont next time.

I think 2 weeks for these contests is way to long, i am pretty sure everyone had submitted their ideas in 1 week and it felt like an eternity waiting for the contest to end.

I would recommend shortening it but that's just my opinion, i don't know if anyone else felt like it lasted to long as well.

Posts: 57

Featured Site

Forge of creation #1 voting !

Awards Showcase

Awards Showcase

Quick Reply

DOTAFire & Defense of the Ancients

DOTA 2 Heroes