Please verify that you are not a bot to cast your vote.
Help SupportOur Growing Community
DOTAFire is a community that lives to help every Dota 2 player take their game to the next level by having open access to all our tools and resources. Please consider supporting us by whitelisting us in your ad blocker!
Want to support DOTAFire with an ad-free experience? You can support us ad-free for less than $1 a month!
Vlads is a support item! The only situation where it really makes sense on a Core-Hero is if you want to have it really early and push really hard using its multiple Auras.
I agree that Cleave is a really strong source of damage later on, but it is not 100% reliable, because:
The angle from which Ember Spirit attacks druing SoF is random. So it could happen that the cleave hits nothing despite 2 heroes standing next to each other. It still is good ofc, especially with sth like Magnus/Enigma/Dark Seer.
If you want to steamroll through the midgame Desolator + Daedalus is better, because the minusarmor is more effective, the earlier you get it. Also helps push towers and increases your Hardcarries DPS.
I would btw prefer getting crystalis before the desolator, just because crit scales so damn well with SoF.
Vlads is a support item! The only situation where it really makes sense on a Core-Hero is if you want to have it really early and push really hard using its multiple Auras.
I agree that Cleave is a really strong source of damage later on, but it is not 100% reliable, because:
The angle from which Ember Spirit attacks druing SoF is random. So it could happen that the cleave hits nothing despite 2 heroes standing next to each other. It still is good ofc, especially with sth like Magnus/Enigma/Dark Seer.
If you want to steamroll through the midgame Desolator + Daedalus is better, because the minusarmor is more effective, the earlier you get it. Also helps push towers and increases your Hardcarries DPS.
I would btw prefer getting crystalis before the desolator, just because crit scales so damn well with SoF.
Have you seen the insane damage cleave on him does?
If you exepct the game to last longet then 30 minutes i would ALWAYS get at least 1 and even rather 2 battle furys. As i stated earlier deso falls off and is a massive waste of money if you dont end the game max 10 minutes after getting it.
I would btw prefer getting crystalis before the desolator, just because crit scales so damn well with SoF.
Desolator gives -7 Armour on your Target as well as 60 Damage, Crystalis gives 30 Damage a 20% chance to deal 75% extra Damage, Demon Edge gives 46 Damage.
I would recomend getting Desolator first, it does more damage than a Crystalis Crit early on (except against DK with maxed out Dragon's Blood), once you're targetting opponents with about 20 Armour, Crystalis does more damage when it Crits, but gram for gram, Deso is better. Don't beleive me?
DK's Armour == 18.74, therefore DK's Physical Damage taken is 100 - 52% == 48% Damage taken
At 18.74 - 7 == 11.74 Armour, he takes 100 - 40% == 60% Damage taken
at lvl 11 Ember has 70.4 Base Daamge, so his total Attack Damage with Phase Boots and Drum of Endurance == 70 + 24 + 9 == 101 (we'l call it 100 though)
Maxed out Sleight of Fist deals 120 Physical Bonus Damage, which is affected by Armour Reduction, but does not get multiplied by Critical Procs
With a Crystalis and Critical Hit Proccing, damage done to a DK with Sleight of Fist:-
== (100 * 1.75 + 120) * 48% == 141.6 Damage dealt
It looks like Crystalis is better, BUT this is only IF you get a Crit..and the increase isn't much. Also bear in mind that at lvl11, you'll be dealing with opponents that only have between 1 - 11 Base Armour, so most won't have much higher than 10 Armour when you include Items. Even at level 25 (Stats included), only Terrorblade and Phantom Lancer have more than 20 Base Armour, with Bounty Hunter and Riki having just over 18.
It takes quite a while for Critical Hits to be more effective than Armour Reduction, and consider this, who's going to be getting more than +5 Armour from Items before you can Farm your Desolator and Crystalis?
P.S. If you're going for a Daedalus 1st, always get the Demon Edge before Crystalis, it gives you more overall Damage. Crystalis 1st is fine if you already have another Damage Item though.
WOOO Xyrus bringing the heat with all the maths, nice analysis. I think I'm gonna play Ember now. Tim, I do agree on battlefury being great, I just don't think it's as reliable.
I do agree on battlefury being great, I just don't think it's as reliable.
I suppose it comes down on being able to capitalise on those windows where Cleave makes the most impact, not to mention, sometimes the fear of getting Cleaved can be pretty effective in luring out Lone Targets...stick together and you get Cleaved, stay apart and you get Picked Off.
WOOO Xyrus bringing the heat with all the maths, nice analysis. I think I'm gonna play Ember now. Tim, I do agree on battlefury being great, I just don't think it's as reliable.
sure this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9kphRKdw9Q isnt reliable, but it is still an amazing item on him, much better then on heroes like phantom assasin, juggernaut or void.
desolator is also a good item on him but it is not core. getting it is a risk becouse it hurts your lategame potential HARD.
ember farms quite slowly and his only comeback mechanism is battle fury, so its by far the safest choice and as a result should be the most commonly bought 1st damage item on him.
sure this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9kphRKdw9Q isnt reliable, but it is still an amazing item on him, much better then on heroes like phantom assasin, juggernaut or void.
desolator is also a good item on him but it is not core. getting it is a risk becouse it hurts your lategame potential HARD.
ember farms quite slowly and his only comeback mechanism is battle fury, so its by far the safest choice and as a result should be the most commonly bought 1st damage item on him.
I hope you know that this triple kill isn't thanks to double Battle Fury and he would do the same if he changed one to Desolator.
Also getting Battle Fury instead of Desolator as 1st item hurts your dmg alot, as it does nearly 0 damage compared to corruption from deso.
Also getting 1st deso is actually boosting your late game potential, as normal people won't allow you to cleave 5 people every sleight and -armor is increasing your single target damage.
"When game is going full ******, you can only go with it. If you start going against it, if you start going half ******, you´re ****ing done for. When Aloha decides to go middle rubick you let him, and you start buying orb of venom on invoker. That's how dota works" -n0tail
I hope you know that this triple kill isn't thanks to double Battle Fury and he would do the same if he changed one to Desolator.
It might have done the trick on that Triple Kill, but Ferrari was going Double Divine Rapier (he also had a spare just in case <}3 ). 35% extra Cleave Damage does more than -7 Armour that far into the game. He just saw an opportunity and capatilised on it. I'm not sure how many other Ember players could do that, but if they can, they'll make the Cleave count for more than Minus Armour in those situations.
I hope you know that this triple kill isn't thanks to double Battle Fury and he would do the same if he changed one to Desolator.
Also getting Battle Fury instead of Desolator as 1st item hurts your dmg alot, as it does nearly 0 damage compared to corruption from deso.
Also getting 1st deso is actually boosting your late game potential, as normal people won't allow you to cleave 5 people every sleight and -armor is increasing your single target damage.
I know this kind of triplekill is an exeption becouse of the dazzle weave and rapier but the battlefury did a LOT of work here.
If you look carefully you will see that the cleave on the first hit alone dealt half lich's HP and a sixth of lycan's.
The hit on lich destroyed lycan. You cant do this with a deso.
So as i said, yes, deso is better at the moment you buy it, but will fall off and severly delay any comback mechanism and delay one of his biggest strenghts, his power to turtle.
But Ember peaks in the midgame (Well or maybe really late where you have 1 or 2 Rapiers) so Desolator helps a lot better to kick *** really hard at that point. You also need to think about your team. Desolator helps pushing faster and also helps your real hardcarry dish out more damage in fights.
But as i said, if the early/midgame is going ****ty, just get BFury to farm up more items a lot faster.
I play a lot of ember spirit and if i have a decent start i can win a lot of games with crystalis and desolator, before i can even finish up the daedalus. (speaking of a 4-5k mmr area)
Overall it just depends on lineups and personal playstyle, if Bfury works for you, nothing speaks against stacking them.
EDIT: @Xyrus: i think you're forgetting that not every hero has as much armor as DK so early in the game; also: crystalis costs half as much as Deso and allows you to crit for 500-600 on SoF, which is pretty cost efficient i would say.
DOTAFire is the place to find the perfect build guide to take your game to the next level. Learn how to play a new hero, or fine tune your favorite DotA hero’s build and strategy.
Terrorblade: http://www.dotafire.com/dota-2/guide/terrorblade-master-of-rats-8657
Allegiance
Notable (9)
Posts: 231
Steam: d4rkdest1ny
Working on a Night Stalker guide!
I made a Clockwerk guide. Check it out if you want.
http://www.dotafire.com/dota-2/guide/the-real-tony-stark-6733
Timminatorr
<Editor>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (57)
Posts: 2376
Xyrus
<Moderator>
Awards Showcase
Established (104)
Posts: 2429
Steam: Xyrus
View My Blog
Check out my carrying guide: http://www.dotafire.com/dota-2/guide/alchemist-shrugged-a-carrying-guide-8022
R-Conqueror
Remarkable (24)
Posts: 503
Steam: R-Conqueror
View My Blog
Xyrus
<Moderator>
Awards Showcase
Established (104)
Posts: 2429
Steam: Xyrus
View My Blog
Working on a Night Stalker guide!
I made a Clockwerk guide. Check it out if you want.
http://www.dotafire.com/dota-2/guide/the-real-tony-stark-6733
Timminatorr
<Editor>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (57)
Posts: 2376
DzikaPanda
<Editor>
Awards Showcase
Notable (16)
Posts: 517
Steam: Kawaii Moe Kid
Xyrus
<Moderator>
Awards Showcase
Established (104)
Posts: 2429
Steam: Xyrus
View My Blog
Working on a Night Stalker guide!
I made a Clockwerk guide. Check it out if you want.
http://www.dotafire.com/dota-2/guide/the-real-tony-stark-6733
Timminatorr
<Editor>
Awards Showcase
Memorable (57)
Posts: 2376
Terrorblade: http://www.dotafire.com/dota-2/guide/terrorblade-master-of-rats-8657
Allegiance
Notable (9)
Posts: 231
Steam: d4rkdest1ny